
The deal between the two fighters was rejected by Showtime. Even so, how would these two do against each other?

Bute is very popular in his native Montreal
Lucian looked very impressive in his last couple fights. He is an extremely strong and large super middleweight. While greatly criticized for not being a part of the Super Six Tournament, I think Bute would’ve been in the finals if he had entered. He does lack marquee names on his resume, though, and fighting Carl Froch would be a definite step up for the Romanian-Canadian.
Since Andre Ward has made it very clear that he feels Bute hasn’t earned a fight with him yet, Froch would’ve made a legitimate opponent. I personally think it would be a great, competitive fight, although I would give the edge to Bute.
Froch, to his credit, has had a punishing schedule for the past two years, and that must’ve taken a toll on him. While Froch has the best chin in boxing, Bute seems fresher and would most likely win via majority decision. Also, Andre Ward exposed Froch somewhat in their match, making Froch look clumsy and ineffective.
While I’m not a personal fan of Froch, I do see him giving Bute his hardest fight since Librado Andrade almost KO’ed Bute in their first match. Carl Froch seems to have the most problem with slick fighters who have speed like Andre Dirrell and Andre Ward. I don’t think he would have issues getting off like he did against the two Americans.
I, for one, hope this fight happens at some point. It’s about time Lucian Bute start fighting some “real” competition. He has definitely been sheltered.